Blog

“Can you Count on Social Security in Retirement?“

 

A few weeks ago, a tweet set off a firestorm online: “US boomers overwhelmingly support higher taxes on younger workers to maintain current Social Security benefits, poll shows.”

After the usual generational bashing died down, the conversation quickly pivoted to a question I get constantly at Van Gelder Financial.  As a CFP® working with folks in their 30s and 40s it’s the elephant in the room: Can I actually count on Social Security being there when I retire?

It’s a fair question. You’ve probably spent your whole adult life hearing that the system is going bankrupt and the trust fund is running dry. While that’s technically true, assuming your future benefit will be a flat zero is the wrong way to build your financial plan.

The Doomsday Headline vs. Reality

According to the 2026 Trustees Report, the main retirement trust fund—Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI)—is projected to run out in 2032. (The Disability Insurance fund is actually in great shape through 2100, but they can’t move money between the two without Congress passing a law). OASI has been paying out more than it takes in since 2021.

But running out of reserves doesn’t mean the checks stop. Social Security can’t borrow funds, so it can only pay out what current workers are paying into the system via payroll taxes. If we hit 2032 with no legislative fixes, you’d still receive 78% of your scheduled benefits in that first year.

A 22% haircut is real, but it’s a lot different than total collapse. If the average Social Security benefit today is around $2,000 a month, a 78% payout is still $1,560. By the year 2100, as the ratio of workers to retirees continues to fall, that payout is projected to drop to 62%. Again, not ideal, but there is still some cash flow you can count on.

How Your Check Is Actually Calculated

A lot of people think Social Security works like a traditional pension: just grind out more years to get a bigger payoff. It doesn’t quite work that way. The actual math boils down to three steps:

1. Indexing your earnings. The Social Security Administration takes your past earnings and adjusts them for national wage growth, right up to the year you turn 60. If you made $36,813 back in 2012, they don’t treat it as $36k today; they scale it up to match current wage indexes. Keep in mind, they only count earnings up to the annual taxable maximum (which is $184,500 in 2026). If you pulled down a quarter-million this year, only that first $184,500 counts toward your future benefit.

2. Averaging your highest 35 years. Next, they take your top 35 earning years, add them all up, and divide by 420 (the number of months in 35 years). It doesn’t matter if you worked 10 years or 35 years—they always divide by 420. This gives you your Average Indexed Monthly Earnings, or AIME.

3. Applying the “Bend Points.” Once they have your AIME, the SSA runs it through a formula that acts like reverse tax brackets. Instead of paying a marginal rate, you earn a percentage back as a benefit. For someone turning 62 in 2026, those bend points look like this:

      • You get 90% of your first $1,286.
      • You get 32% of the amount between $1,286 and $7,749.
      • You get 15% of anything above $7,749.

Because of this progressive structure, lower-income workers get a much larger percentage of their working income replaced than higher earners.

The Impact of When You Claim

Let’s say your AIME is $5,000. Under this formula, your monthly benefit at full retirement age (67) would be $2,345 (which is almost 47% of your AIME).

But timing is everything. If you pull the trigger early at 62, you take a roughly 30% penalty, dropping that check to $1,642 a month. If you can afford to hold off until age 70, you get a 24% delayed retirement credit, bumping that same benefit up to $2,908 a month.

Will Congress Actually Let the Cut Happen?

While the math says 2032 is the deadline, it’s highly unlikely lawmakers will stand by and let a 22% benefit cut hit millions of Americans. Congress has always stepped in to patch the system before, usually at the eleventh hour.

There are a few well-known levers they can pull to close the gap and keep benefits at 100%:

      • Raising the Payroll Tax Cap: Currently, you only pay Social Security taxes on your first $184,500 of income (in 2026). Removing or raising that ceiling would generate significant new revenue.
      • Increasing the Tax Rate: Bumping up the payroll tax percentage slightly for both workers and employers.
      • Pushing Back Full Retirement Age: Gradually increasing the full retirement age beyond 67 for younger workers to account for longer life expectancies.
      • Adjusting the Math: Tweaking how Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLA) are calculated, or reducing benefits for high-net-worth retirees who don’t strictly rely on the income.

Most serious proposals rely on a combination of these changes, phased in over time.

Whether I’m dialing in a client’s long-term projection or working with someone who is already retired the advice is the same. Don’t write Social Security off completely. Plan for a conservative haircut, dial in your own investments, and control what you can control.